Series 4 - Echoes in Action
Echo 17 — When the Map Changed Around Them
When we search for our ancestors, we tend to think of place as something fixed.
A person lived in Cumberland County.
Another lived in Harnett County.
Another lived in Moore County.
But the geography recorded beside our ancestors' names was not nearly so permanent.
County boundaries changed. New counties were created. Townships were divided and renamed. A family could appear to have moved from one place to another between census years when, in fact, they may have remained on the same land while the name of the place changed around them.
That is why the old townships of the Sandhills matter.
A New Way of Dividing the Counties
Following North Carolina's 1868 Constitution, counties were divided into townships. These smaller geographic units became important ways of identifying communities and administering local government.
Their creation coincided with an especially important moment in African American history.
The 1870 census was the first federal census after emancipation to enumerate formerly enslaved people by name as members of their own households.
For many of our ancestors, therefore, those early township names are among the first geographic markers we have for them as free people.
In Cumberland County, the post-1868 townships included Babers, Black River, Carvers Creek, Cedar Creek, Cross Creek, Flea Hill, Gray's Creek, Manchester, Pearces Mill, Rockfish, and Seventy-First.
In Harnett County, they included Averasboro, Barbecue, Black River, Buckhorn, Grove, Hectors Creek, Johnsonville, Lillington, Neills Creek, Stewart's Creek, and Upper Little River.
And in Moore County, they included Ben Salem, Carthage, Crains Creek, Deep River, Greenwood, McNeill, Mineral Springs, Pocket, Ritters, and Sheffields.
But those lists are only a snapshot.
The township map continued to change.
When Barbecue Became Anderson Creek
Harnett County provides a particularly good example.
Anderson Creek Township does not appear among the county's original post-1868 townships.
It was established later, in part from territory that had been included in Barbecue Township.
That distinction becomes very real when we look at the census.
My own ancestors appear in Barbecue Township in the 1870 census. Ten years later, in 1880, they appear in Anderson Creek Township.
At first glance, that could suggest that the family moved.
But the records raise another possibility—and an important lesson for family historians.
The people may have stayed put. The township changed.
Sometime between those two censuses, Anderson Creek Township came into existence, incorporating at least part of what had previously been Barbecue Township. So an ancestor whose residence was recorded as Barbecue in 1870 could later be recorded in Anderson Creek without packing a wagon, selling a piece of land, or moving a household.
The boundary crossed them.
That is precisely why we have to read historical records using the geography of their time, not ours.
The Map Kept Evolving
Anderson Creek was not the only later addition.
Harnett County would also gain Duke Township, which was later renamed Erwin.
Moore County's township structure changed as well, with Pinehurst and Sandhills established later.
These changes are more than interesting bits of local history. They can determine where we look for an ancestor.
If we search only for a place name we recognize today, we may miss records created when that same piece of land belonged to another township.
And sometimes the change was even larger than a township boundary.
Where Is Lee County?
There is another name noticeably missing from our original post-1868 township lists:
Lee County.
That is because Lee County did not exist.
It was created in 1907 from portions of Moore and Chatham counties.
So someone living in what is now Lee County could not have been recorded as a resident of Lee County in the 1870, 1880, or 1900 federal census.
If we are looking for that person, we have to look at the map that existed then.
A family living on land that later became part of Lee County might appear in an earlier record under Moore County or Chatham County.
Again:
The family may not have moved. The boundary did.
Townships Can Help Us Find the Community
For African American genealogy, these distinctions can be particularly valuable.
The 1870 census is often treated as a starting line because it is the first census in which formerly enslaved people generally appear by name.
But simply finding an ancestor in 1870 is not the end of the search.
Look at the township.
Then look at the people living around them.
Who were their neighbors?
Which surnames appear repeatedly?
Where were the nearby churches?
Where were the cemeteries?
Who owned land nearby?
Which white families had been enslavers in that same area before emancipation?
Where do those Black families appear in 1880?
And if the township name changes between censuses, find out whether the family moved—or whether the township boundary moved instead.
That question can completely change the direction of the research.
Names That Still Speak
Some of the old township names remain familiar across the Sandhills:
Carvers Creek.
Seventy-First.
Barbecue.
Upper Little River.
Deep River.
Greenwood.
Anderson Creek.
Others, such as Flea Hill, Pocket, Hectors Creek, and Sheffields, may be less familiar today.
But on an old census page, each one is a clue.
A township takes us from a county covering hundreds of square miles and places our ancestors in a much smaller landscape—a landscape of farms, creeks, roads, churches, schools, cemeteries, and neighboring families.
And once we begin comparing those landscapes across time, something else becomes apparent.
Maps record history, too.
A line drawn across a county could give a community a new name. A new township could appear between one census and the next. In 1907, an entirely new county called Lee could emerge from land that generations had known as Moore or Chatham.
Our ancestors lived through all of those changes.
So when we find someone in Barbecue Township in 1870 and Anderson Creek Township in 1880, we should resist the temptation to immediately send them down the road.
First, we ask what every good family historian eventually learns to ask:
Did my ancestors move—or did the map?
Sometimes, the answer is the map.
And understanding that difference can help us find the people we thought we had lost.


